Written by Rowdy Muir
“Redaction”
The Missing Common Denominator
Written by Rowdy
Muir
The purpose of a “Blog” is to get
a discussion going. This article certain received a lot of attention. I want to
thank all the many positive comments. Thanks to Chuck Maxwell with helping with
proper language.
However, as a leader I need to own
my mistake in misrepresenting some of the language.
First, the numbers were to reflect fatalities and
entrapment fires not that if you were in these categories that you had an 80% chance of death.
Second, the numbers were to
reflect all firefighters not just wildland firefighters.
So with that being said, here is
the redacted version of the article. Again, please except my apologies.
**************************************************************
I appreciate the
article that was recently published in Wildfire
Magazine “Common Denominators on Tragedy Fires – Updated for a New (Human)
Fire Environment” written by Matt Holmstrom. There were three things in the
article that captured my attention.
- 19% of fatalities or entrapments involve fire personnel in the first five years of their career. “This includes all firefighters not just wildland firefighter”
- 54% of fatalities or entrapments involve a Single Resource Boss
- Most fatalities or entrapments occur between 14:48 and 16:42. “However there are many fatalities or entrapments that occur outside of this time frame”
It isn’t any different today then in 1910, when Edward Crockett "Ed" Pulaski gathered his local firefighters and headed in to protect the town of Wallace, Idaho and ended up being cut off from the flaming front. Trying to do the moral and ethical thing, protecting life and property. It seems that within our culture or tribe we have missed a very important aspect in the common denominators of wildfire tragedies: we have lost more lives in so called structure protection or protecting the home lands than anything else.
More specifically, the protection of structures and home lands by firefighters who have an emotional attachment to those structures or lands.
There is evidence that shows when you are emotionally attached or have ownership in something, you don’t always follow the book. You react and make decisions differently than you might when you are out of your communities, state, or geographical area.
The question was asked to Preston Cline, Director of Wharton Leadership Ventures, who works with the McNulty Leadership Program and The Wharton School, University of Pennsylvania about emotional attachments and do people do things differently when emotionally attached?
Preston acknowledges that there is little to no neurological work in this area. However he suggest a couple of things.
- One is the idea of intellectual stabilization. As an EMT, you need to be able to block out someone's screaming so you can stop the bleeding. You can intellectually rationalize that the pain is required. When you have to work on friends or children, however, it doesn't matter. You lose the objectivity because you don't want to hurt or lose your friend or a child.
- Secondly, is the idea of the "other space." I can go out into the world and risk my life, because I know if it gets bad I can retreat to home. If "home," even metaphorically, is threatened, I have to fix that before I can do anything else. This notion is probably best expressed by Maslow's hierarchy of need. I can only be altruistic once water, food, and shelter are secured. Start messing with those, and I need to rethink everything.
- Lastly, if you are a community member, you are part of a tribe. You need to show the tribe you have done everything you could so as to not lose standing.
I will suggest that in addition to the “Fire Orders” or “Watchout Situations” that there is an additional “Common Denominator” that can and will save lives if we only learn to acknowledge it.
History has shown that we have lost many agency firefighters who had an emotional attachment to the structures there were trying to save. Those firefighters are part of a “tribe,” and their hierarchy of needs real.
Here are at least thirteen incidents where this has occurred:
1959 - Decker Fire – (6) El Cariso Hotshots died in close proximity to their station
1977 - Cart Creek – (3) local Forest Service employees on their own District
1980 – Mack Lake – (1) local firefighter
1990 – Dude – (6) local Perryville handcrew members
1990 – Wasatch State Park – (2) local dozer operators
2000 – North Stansbury – (2) local handcrew members
2001 – 30 Mile – (4) local handcrew members
2003 – Cramer – (2) local Forest Service employees on their own District
2006 – Esperanza – (5) local engine 57
2006 – Devils Den – (1) local Fire Operations Specialist in his backyard
2007 – Neola North – (3) Retired District FMO his son and a local rancher
2013 – Yarnell – (19) local handcrew near their own duty station
2016 – Twisp River – (3) local engine members
And the near misses—Clay Springs in 2012, where 3 firefighter were burned doing initial attack next to their fire station and community. There are many more.
Just something to consider. If you have five or more years of service, are Single Resource Boss qualified, you’re on the fireline in the afternoon, and you are fighting a fire on your own district, in your own community, near your station, with an emotional attachment to the people or to the landscape and what’s on it—the chances of a fatality could be higher than the 80% mentioned above.
As the “Life First” safety journey continues to play out for the Forest Service, I will make this suggestion and challenge: As you have discussions with your cooperators and you talk among your peers and subordinates remind them in addition to the ”Fire Order” or “Watchout Situation”—there is one more “Common Denominator” –working in situations where you have emotional attachments. You think differently, you make irrational, risky decisions, your emotions take over –sometimes with very high consequences.
So STOP, THINK,” AM I EMOTIONALY ATTACHED”? Then TALK, and ACT.”
***************************************************
About the Author: Rowdy Muir is the U.S. Forest Service Flaming Gorge District Ranger, L-380 Lead Instructor, and former Type 1 Incident Commander.
No comments:
Post a Comment
********
The WFLDP seeks to build and support an online community in which wildland fire professionals can interact.
We invite respectful discussion; however, the realities of online culture is such that anonymous posts and posts from children under the age of 13 are not accepted.
All comments are monitored by our editorial staff for appropriateness in meeting the mission of the WFLDP prior to posting to the blog. We do not discriminate against any views, but we reserve the right not to post comments.
Individuals posting comments are fully responsible for everything that they submit.
Comments submitted after hours and on holidays/weekends will be reviewed as early as possible the next business day.
Our complete blog policy can be found at http://www.fireleadership.gov/committee/reports/Blog_Policy_Jan2010.pdf.
A yellow box will appear after you submit your comment notifying you that your comment will be reviewed.